Library › Mechanisms › Gears ·

Ferguson's mechanical paradox (19 / 20 / 21 tooth wheels on one pin)

Why do the three wheels of Ferguson's paradox turn differently? · Hardware · basis: Xem Studio design following Brown No. 504 (1868)

Also called: ferguson's paradox, mechanical paradox, paradox gear train, epicyclic paradox, paradoja mecánica de Ferguson, Fergusons mechanisches Paradoxon

Exact dimensions. True size, with no tolerance added.

sizes
5 in table

Notes

  • Resize: multiply every length by one factor k and the motion stays identical: angles, ratios, timing and the formulas below do not change, because a mechanism's motion depends only on the ratios of its lengths. Here, scales with k: centre distances; stays the same: sun (fixed), idler, wheels, turns per arm turn.
  • Resize: Gears scale by the module m (pitch Ø = m·z, centre distance = m·(z₁ + z₂)/2): keep the tooth counts so the ratio stays, and choose a standard module (0.5, 0.8, 1, 1.25, 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3).
  • Resize: fit clearances stay in mm (a slide fit is the same gap at any size); keep every printed wall and pin at least two nozzle widths; mass grows with k³ but part strength only with k², so at k = 2 parts are about 8× heavier and 4× stronger: check pins and thin links when scaling up.
  • A 20-tooth sun is fixed; an arm turning about it carries a thick idler and, on a second pin, three loose wheels of 19, 20 and 21 teeth that all mesh with the idler. Carry the arm once round: the 20 T wheel does not turn at all, the 21 T wheel turns 1/21 of a turn forwards and the 19 T wheel 1/19 of a turn backwards — each wheel turns (1 − 20/N) turns per turn of the arm, the idler only setting the direction.
  • Three wheels on one pin at one centre distance (25 mm) with different tooth counts need profile shifts: +0.54 m on the 19 T and -0.46 m on the 21 T, 20° involutes meshing an unshifted 30 T idler (tips shortened to Ø31.5) with no backlash drawn; the 20 T wheels are catalog gears.
  • Brown's No. 504 (Ferguson's mechanical paradox, 1764): the demonstration behind his orrery.
  • Parts (each has its own page): spur-gears-module-1, spur-gear-m1-30t-w26-b6, spur-gear-m1-19t-x054-b6, spur-gear-m1-21t-xm046-b6, paradox-arm-25-25-b6, dowel-pins-metric.
  • Brown's movement No. 504 (1868) shows it; this model is a Xem Studio design following his figure, every part at true size.

Ferguson's mechanical paradox size chart

parametervalue
sun (fixed)20 T, module 1
idler30 T × 26 face
wheels19 / 20 / 21 T on one pin
centre distances25 + 25 mm
turns per arm turn−1/19, 0, +1/21

Where the files are

Other publishers' files are linked, not hosted. "verify" = check the license at the link before commercial use.

Henry T. Brown (1868, public domain)Five Hundred and Seven Mechanical Movements — scan on archive.orgwebPublisher's page; dimensions are facts
507movements.comBrown's movement No. 504: figure, his text and an animationwebPublisher's page; dimensions are facts

Free files

★ Free files 1 parts. Xem Studio design: free to use, print and sell things from; not to be republished as files. Xem Studio Design License. index.json

Use this part in your AI. Your AI gets the exact sizes and files straight from Xem and can design a mount, case or adapter around it. Direct downloads here are limited to one file every 10 minutes; through your AI they are unlimited.

Connect Xem to your AI (free, no account, about a minute)
https://xemstudio.com/mcp
  1. Claude: Add to Claude
  2. ChatGPT (Plus or higher): open Connectors → Advanced → turn on Developer mode → Create → paste the address, no authentication → Create.
  3. Cursor: install with one click. VS Code: install with one click.
Other apps and full steps
fergusons-paradox-mechanism-assemblyAssembled mechanism, all parts placed at one pose (STEP keeps each part separate)STEP · STL
Let your AI pull this. Add https://xemstudio.com/mcp to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or any MCP client (free, no account, one minute) and it can look up exact sizes, mating fits and free STEP/STL from every chat.
Set it up →

Plain text: sheet.txt · JSON: /api/geometry?object=fergusons-paradox-mechanism

Ferguson's mechanical paradox (19 / 20 / 21 tooth wheels on one pin), isometric render of a generated part
Render of fergusons-paradox-mechanism-assembly from the free STEP; not to scale.

Fits with

Questions

Why do the three wheels of Ferguson's paradox turn differently?

A 20-tooth sun is fixed; an arm turning about it carries a thick idler and, on a second pin, three loose wheels of 19, 20 and 21 teeth that all mesh with the idler. Carry the arm once round: the 20 T wheel does not turn at all, the 21 T wheel turns 1/21 of a turn forwards and the 19 T wheel 1/19 of a turn backwards — each wheel turns (1 − 20/N) turns per turn of the arm, the idler only setting the direction.

What is the rule for a wheel on the arm?

Relative to the frame it turns 1 − N_sun/N per turn of the arm (idler ignored): 0 for 20 T, +1/21 and −1/19 here.